UNRAVELLING MORE “RED TAPE”

 

by: Shelly Harris / Entertainment Attorney

                            

QUESTION:  

 

I signed with an "indie" label as a solo artist over two years ago.  According to my contract, I was able to deliver them the record I had already recorded as my demo, with just a few tweeks made to the production, which they would then have mastered and distributed. However, to date, they have still not released my record. What can I do?

 

 

ANSWER: 

 

 As always, your “remedy” for this situation will turn on the particular provisions of your agreement with the label. At the outset, I will say non-release of your CD/album after two years is far too long. Most labels distribute within six months after mastering. Otherwise, the music may become “stale,” artist(s) lose momentum, etc. 

 

You haven’t stated the label’s explanation for the non-release, but there are usually two or three reasons why a label will “shelve” an album.  First, they may be having financial difficulties or marketing and distribution problems.  If the label is in danger of going bankrupt, the album may never be released, unless you “buy” out your own contract. However, if you had a “guaranteed release” provision in your contract, which indicates the date by which a satisfactory album must be released, then, typically, you send the label notice that the agreement is terminated, and you are free to take the album to another label after reimbursing any costs to the original label.

 

Other reasons a label might legitimately shelve an album is because of its content or quality. There could be obscenity or legal issues regarding titles, artwork, song ownership or “sampling” that have not been cleared by the agreed upon release date.  If you need to get “clearances” or licenses for use of any of the material on the record, you may have to pay for such arrangements yourself. (Whether you or the label is responsible for the costs and arrangement for such legal clearances should be directly stipulated in your contract.) 

 

Finally, another reason a label might refuse to release an album, is because they deem it not commercially satisfactory or marketable. Usually only majors will put such creative control-type clauses in their contracts these days, whereas indie labels will usually only require the record to be technically satisfactory (professionally made). 

 

A way to attempt to avert the dreaded “creative control” tug-o-war between a label and artist is to include a provision in the contract specifically stating that you, the artist, will retain such control over the artwork and the recorded product.  An indie lable may comply with this provision, while most major labels won’t.  This is why many artists and bands that are at household name status have had episodes where there were long delays in releases of their albums, or where such artists have been told to “go back to the drawing board” altogether.  

 

Because you are at an indie label, however, it is more likely that financial problems or mismanagement at the label are the reasons for the delay in distributing and promoting your album.  Look at the specific terms of the agreement with your attorney, and see what time limits may have been included, or if there is indeed a guaranteed release provision. Also keep the lines of communication open, and, if they are unresponsive, legal “leveraging” and negotiations may be required.  

 

Write to Shelly Harris at: shellyharrislaw@aol.com

 

 

Back to Top

 

Web Design By:
Hungry Mind Design

 All Rights Reserved © Hungry Mind  Design2003